@Xeon, of course the question "Better than what?" makes sense to the statement, "I know a lot of Black men and women who did and most of them came out better." In fact, that question ALWAYS makes that most sense when someone say that something is better or worse.
If you want to describe something as not making sense, lets look at your statement;
"...people who generally serve in the military are better after they leave the military than when were prior to entering the service for the most obvious reasons."
What is obvious about that? We have already discussed that people in the military suffer from PTSD, homelessness, suicide, all at rates higher than people who did not go into the military. Your statement makes no sense in light of these facts. Also how can you be so confident that if people did something else with their time, like go to college, learn a trade, or just get a job, that they would be worse off than if they went into the military?
As Chris mentioned the negative outcomes of military service has to do with the job you are in and other factors. And as already stated there are of course people who come out better as a result of Military service, Chris is an example. However Chris' alternative was JAIL! I'd recommend anyone go into the military, every day of the week, if the option was jail.
I have one simple question for you Xeon: Do you think that all young men and women should serve in the military?
@Cynique, I'm not sure why you are accusing me of lecturing, and not anyone else, including yourself.. We are debating the issues and making arguments . But I think I get why you are so defensive of my critique of the military. I think you are receiving it as if I'm personally attacking all the men in your life who have served,
I'm not doing that.
Again, I'm not focusing on Individuals. I like Chris, and am glad he had a great experience, but I'm not going to judge the entire armed forces on his experience, any more than I would judge it on the experience of my father's, who was able to show his premature death was related to his military service.
I'm also not sure why you use adjectives like "revolted" and "despised" in describing my feeling about the armed services. I did not use these words, nor do I feel this way. Indeed, I wrote that we NEED the military, because we do. I'm only advocating that we treat the people better than we currently do.
But improving how we treat our military personnel will never improve if we all bury our heads in the sand and act like there aren't any problems that need correcting. I also believe that Black men, in particular, are presented with so few options that the military is often their only decent choice. I don't feel this should be the case either.
So sure Cynique, that is the "world as it exists," but that does not mean we can't try to change it.
@CDBurns, interestingly I went to a high school that had a class that taught us little life skills, like writing a checks, banks account, even how to buy a used car.