Here are the results so far. The survey was prompted by a question posed in the conversation What's Wrong With This Picture? I’d encourage everyone to check out this conversation. During the conversation, you'll learn if the makeup artist was Black. You definitely read a wide variety of opinions; some of the comments may change the way you feel about this photo or they may strengthen your opinion. Here are the results so far:
None of the non-Black respondents did saw the photo as racist and all of them agreed the photo was flattering.
The responses from the Black Males were split. Half agreed the photo was racist and half felt it was the photo was flattering
10% of respondents were Black men, 10% were not Black (evenly split between male and female). 80% of the respondents were Black women
The following are Responses from Just Black Women 80% of All Respondents
Photo Racist and Not Flattering: 37%
Photo Racist and Flattering: 3%
Photo Not Racist and Not Flattering: 34%
Photo Not Racist and Flattering: 26%
These are the Comments from the survey respondents (comments were optional):
“Why is a picture of a black woman wearing red lipstick, smiling broadly about something that made her bring her hands to her face so offensive? Subjective reactions to it are more about how white people will view the picture rather than how black people would. Many black women look this way and a broad smile is not something any woman should have to be judged for. I'd be interested in hearing Viola's comments about this candid shot.
I'm actually American and of African Ascent ”
“It is certainly not flattering, but not racist”
“If black folk find this in any way racist, I will be edified.”
“Viola Davis is such a beautiful black women. I had always admired her ""Blackness"" and darkness. It seems that they used the worst picture of her to make a mockery for Black women. Bottom line is that I think it was intentional to make her look like an animal. Blessings to Viola...”
“God have mercy on (them) whoever!”
“Ms Davis is a beautiful Black woman - end of story!”
“For years the publication Time has been subtly racist. In my younger years I subscribed to this magazine, but after noting how snide and subtly derisive this publication can be when the subject of an article is black, I wrote them an angry letter and dropped my subscription. I see from this picture, where they seemed to wait until they found the most unflattering posture and snapped the picture, they haven't changed at all. Regards, Pat”
“I don't understand the question. Is this a picture of Viola in a role, or is it just a picture. She has many different looks, she wears her hair in many different styles, so in what context is the question being asked.????”
“I never thought of the picture as racist until this survey. My first reaction to it when I first saw it was to just think it was not a good picture, period. The colors don't mix at all. It's too many colors, actually, for something so serious and a woman of her stature. She's not a pop star, but a great and studious actress. I kind of feel like I know what they were going for- joy and all that- but they missed the mark. I am also tired of them making Viola into some charity case who is ecstatic she survived abject poverty and childhood trauma. I get that, that's great and all. But, we are just proud of her as a beautiful artist and woman who is a joy to watch in all her diverse roles like a Meryl Streep or Kate Winslet. We're not framing her in her past.”
“I am sure this wasn't her best photo of the evening. It definitely brings to mind the old red lipped big teeth grinning Negro. Not to be ashamed of showing a toothy smile or wearing red lipstick...but she's only a hair away from wearing a bandana and apron here. She's beautiful, this doesn't really look like Viola Davis!”
“I am curious what is racist about it? I think she looks beautiful. However it does look like a lot of photoshop.”
“It show how ridicules we look we try to adopt white culture. Hair makeup etc.”
“An expert professional photographer could have gotten a better photo of Viola Davis; the photo is not flattering at all.”
“This is a photo of Ms. Davis. I feel it may not be the most flattering of photos, but I don't see anything racist about an actual photo. She is smiling and posing.”
“Somehow, when profiling women who are not of color, they seem to be photographed in a more appealing profile.”